New Report and Ruling Dim Philip Vance’s Hopes of Postconviction Relief
MCF-Rush City, MN — Serving life in prison for a crime he says he didn’t commit, Philip Vance’s hopes for freedom took a blow last month when a judge denied his fifth postconviction relief petition. Convicted in 2004 for a deadly robbery in South Saint Paul, Vance has been denied in every attempted appeal and petition.
Last month was no different. Judge Michael Mayer denied Vance a new trial and an evidentiary hearing.
The ruling comes four months after Minnesota’s Conviction Review Unit (CRU) released their investigative report on Vance and “found a lack of reliable evidence to support Vance’s innocence claim” and concluded that they “cannot recommend vacation of his conviction.”
Vance’s support team told UR they’re appealing the latest denial. “We will continue to pursue every legal avenue available to ensure that Philip’s case is given the full and fair consideration it deserves.”
Coverage of Philip Vance’s ‘Wrongful Conviction’
Among the litany of issues Vance deems as reasons for his case to be heard again include errors by the trial court, errors by the prosecutor, ineffective assistance of trial counsel, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, testimonial recantations, and that his case was investigated by the Minnesota Gang Strike Force, which was criminally disbanded years after Vance’s conviction.
Judge Mayer’s 19-page ruling on March 24 was in response to Vance’s legal team filing an amended version of his fifth petition for postconviction relief in February 2025, asserting that they had new evidence, that Vance was denied a fair trial, and that various court irregularities had occurred.
The denial order by Judge Mayer leaned heavily on the CRU’s final report on Vance, which was finalized in November and filed in district court on January 5, 2026. The report included over a thousand pages of supporting docs — view them in Unicorn Riot’s Vault Server.
Vance had submitted his application to the CRU on July 30, 2021, asking the unit to review his conviction. The CRU was formed earlier that year from a partnership between the Great North Innocence Project and the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office “to identify, remedy, and prevent wrongful convictions.” The underfunded unit accepted Vance’s filing and said they started investigating his case in August 2021.
Limited Funds Stunt Minnesota’s Conviction Review Unit — Families Want Expediency
After reviewing “thousands of pages of case-related materials, listen[ing] to hundreds of hours of recordings, and interview[ing] eight witnesses,” the CRU publicized their final report specifying its investigative findings.
The 112-page report essentially refutes each of the 12 points made in Vance’s application while noting they did find evidence of improper police work. “The CRU did not find Vance’s claims to be supported by evidence that is reliable and corroborated by other, independent evidence,” the report’s conclusion states.
“Although Vance’s legal team has identified some questionable tactics used by law enforcement in the Sabreen’s investigation, the CRU found his claim of innocence unpersuasive because it cannot be corroborated by credible evidence.”
CRU Report on Philip Vance
In Judge Mayer’s denial he notes how important the CRU report was, saying that initially the court assumed “the assertions in [Vance’s] petition are true,” however, “it seems paradoxical that the court should assume as true facts that an independent agency (CRU), engaged at Petitioner’s request, already found to not have indicia of trustworthiness.”
Dakota County Attorney Kathy Keena, who prosecuted Vance’s murder trial in 2004, released a statement that read, “I respect the court’s decision and I appreciate the CRU for the thorough evaluation of this matter. Our office remains committed to transparency and to upholding the integrity of the justice system.”
Advocate for Philip Vance, Nikki Holliday, told UR, “This decision raises serious constitutional concerns, including violations of due process.”
“The State of Minnesota appears to apply exoneration standards inconsistently, even when similar errors and falsities exist. This inconsistency is deeply concerning and raises serious questions that cannot be ignored,” she said.
The petition was denied despite the legal team having “uncovered new material evidence the Conviction Review Unit never investigated,” noted Holliday.
Vance’s CRU report was the fourth investigation finalized and publicly released by the CRU out of over a thousand-plus applications they’ve received.
The unit had previously recommended vacated convictions for three men serving life for murder in the state, Thomas Rhodes, Brian Pippitt, and Edgar Barrientos. The cases went through different forms of litigation after CRU’s investigative report was filed but all three have since been released from prison, though it took Pippitt more than a year and a half after the CRU report because Aitkin County continues to fight the case in court.
Vance, who faced retaliation by prison officials for his role in a prison protest in September 2023, previously told UR that when he applied for the CRU he believed in the unit. But after waiting for so many years for the investigation on his case to be completed, among other reasons, he felt the unit had become “a joke.”
As Vance serves life, currently housed in MCF-Rush City, he hasn’t given up hope that he can get his case heard again in court. His support team said the “failures” of previous rulings “are now central to the appeal as we fight for a full and fair review.”
Follow us on X (aka Twitter), Facebook, YouTube, Vimeo, Instagram, Mastodon, Threads, BlueSky and Patreon.
Please consider a tax-deductible donation to help sustain our horizontally-organized, non-profit media organization:
Recent Unicorn Riot Prison Coverage:
Slavery is Legal in Minnesota. These Groups are Working to Change That. [Jan. 2026]
Prisoners in Minnesota are earning less than a dollar an hour making products for Disney. Organizers and former inmates gathered at a press conference to share what they’ve learned — or experienced firsthand — about the exploitative prison labor system in Minnesota.
White Supremacist Mass Shooter of Protesters To Be Released From Prison in First Week of 2026 [Jan. 2026]
A decade after shooting five unarmed Black protesters in Minneapolis, white supremacist Allen “Lance” Scarsella is set to be released from his prison sentence on January 5, 2026.
Bryan Hooper Sr. Freed From Wrongful Conviction After ‘Sordid’ 27 Years in Prison [Sept. 2025]
Bryan Hooper Sr. walked out of a Minnesota prison on Sept. 4 after 9,999 days of captivity for a murder he was wrongfully convicted of.
Mail Censorship, Book Bans, and Misconduct – A Letter From Federal Prison [Aug. 2025]
Anson Chi says he’s a political prisoner dealing with mail censorship, book bans, and misconduct by federal corrections officers.
After 27 Years in Prison, Prosecutors Call For Bryan Hooper’s Murder Conviction to be Vacated [Aug. 2025]
Bryan Hooper, another wrongfully convicted Black man in Minnesota, is hoping to be freed from his life sentence after the state’s key trial witness recently admitted to the murder Hooper was convicted for.
New Conviction Integrity Unit Agrees to Review Mahdi Ali’s Case [June 2025]
After fifteen and a half years in prison for a crime he says he didn’t commit, a fresh burst of hope has worked its way into the cell of Mahdi Ali. His legal team has filed an application with Hennepin County’s new Conviction Integrity Unit and recently received assurance from the unit’s director, Andrew Markquart, that the office would give Ali’s case its “full attention.”
Coverage of Philip Vance’s ‘Wrongful Conviction’ [Numerous Article and Videos]
Serving a life sentence for a deadly robbery in South St. Paul in 2002, Philip Vance has always insisted he is innocent. Officers from the corrupt and disbanded Metro Gang Strike Force were the investigators of Vance’s case and his 2004 conviction was prosecuted based on testimonies which have since been recanted. Unicorn Riot has published several reports and videos bringing further context to Vance’s case, including a slew of documents and an analysis.
Living Life on His Own Terms: Reflections from Former Political Prisoner Eric King on His Release [Dec. 2024]
Former political prisoner Eric King was released from prison on December 12, 2023, after spending nearly 10 years behind bars. Seven and a half of the ten were in solitary confinement, with five and a half being consecutive. As he walked off the Florence Federal Correctional Complex property toward a small crowd of friends and supporters, his wife and child ran up to him, embracing him tightly. King spoke with Unicorn Riot in December 2024, reflecting on his release day a year earlier and how life in the halfway house was.
Recanted Jailhouse Testimonies Lead to Renewed Calls to Release Bobo and Ferguson [July 2024]
Family members and advocates of two men serving life sentences in Minnesota — Deaunteze Bobo and Jermaine Ferguson — renewed their demands for their loved ones to be released from prison, saying they were wrongfully convicted.
Target, ‘Junk Science’ and Unreliable Testimonies: The Contentious Conviction of 15-Year-Old Mahdi Ali [June 2024]
Overlooked details have emerged casting serious doubt on Mahdi Hassan Ali’s conviction for a 2010 triple murder, as well as the integrity of the investigation by the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) and the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office. “I was the perfect scapegoat.” – Mahdi Hassan Ali
Marvin Haynes Exonerated and Released From Prison After 19 Years [Jan. 2024]
In a historic ruling, Hennepin County Judge William Koch vacated Marvin Haynes’ murder conviction, dismissed his charges with prejudice, and ordered his release from prison where he was sentenced to serve life. Haynes walked out of MCF-Stillwater as an exonerated man into the loving arms of his family and supporters on Dec. 11, 2023.
The Case of Marvin Haynes – An Investigative Series & Film [2023]
Despite no evidence tying Marvin Haynes to a 2004 murder and Marvin’s consistent claims of innocence, Haynes has remained in prison for nearly two decades based off of coerced testimony of jailed teenagers. We examine his case in our investigative series.
‘Let Me Pay My Taxes’ Says Incarcerated Industry Worker [Nov. 2023]
From inside a Minnesota prison cell, an incarcerated worker in the state’s Prison Industries Enhancement Certification Program (PIECP) is demanding the Department of Corrections (DOC) allow him to pay his taxes. Kashaun Pierce Sr. said for the last seven years he’s been trying to pay his taxes but the DOC has been listing him as an independent contractor.
Family Seeks Answers Months After Cristian Rivera-Coba’s Death in Anoka County Jail [Sept. 2023]
Cristian Rivera-Coba died in the Anoka County Jail in July. Months later, his family and advocates are still left seeking information about the circumstances surrounding his death and demanding an investigation into the jail where, only weeks before Cristian died, 24-year-old Miles Jackson was also found dead in a cell.
Prisoners Face Retaliation for Protest at MCF-Stillwater [Sept. 2023]
An email sent to the media on the morning of Sept. 12 from a person housed in B East details some of the retaliatory actions by corrections officers and the “aggravated” charges that those demanding humane treatment inside Stillwater now face for their actions.
‘I Can’t Take This Shit No More’: Alabama Prisoner Takes a Stand [Aug. 2023]
Derrol Shaw’s attempted escape from Donaldson Correctional Facility in Alabama speaks to a wider human rights crisis in the state’s corrupt, neglectful and deadly prison system.
Limited Funds Stunt Minnesota’s Conviction Review Unit — Families Want Expediency [July 2023]
Created to prevent, identify, and remedy wrongful convictions, Minnesota’s first-ever Conviction Review Unit had completed only one official investigation in nearly two years.
Minnesota Inmate Calls on DOC to ‘Value Us as Human’ [June 2023]
Unicorn Riot received a statement from Kashaun Damon Pierce Sr., a man housed at MCF-Faribault. Pierce provides a short glimpse into the state prison system and calls out what he calls the dehumanization of prisoners as a fundamental issue.
